We can use the production possibilities model to examine choices in the production of goods and services. 2(163/4)23\frac{2\left(16^{3 / 4}\right)}{2^3} Here, the opportunity cost is lowest at Plant 3 and greatest at Plant 1. The bowed-out production possibilities curve for Alpine Sports illustrates the law of increasing opportunity cost. c. Eliminates market failures created by government. For example, there might be a trade-off between hunting for rabbits or gathering berries. We may conclude that, as the economy moved along this curve in the direction of greater production of security, the opportunity cost of the additional security began to increase. We see in Figure 2.5 The Combined Production Possibilities Curve for Alpine Sports that, beginning at point A and producing only skis, Alpine Sports experiences higher and higher opportunity costs as it produces more snowboards. b. Given the labor and the capital available at both plants, it can produce the combinations of the two goods at the two plants shown. a. The goods and services that maximize profits for businesses. c. Shortages of building materials and a slower recovery from the storm b. Plant R has a comparative advantage in producing calculators. Also, I guess that the law of increasing opportunity cost is the opposite of economies of scale. d. A change in a determinant of demand shifts the supply curve. If Alpine Sports were to produce still more snowboards in a single month, it would shift production to Plant 2, the facility with the next-lowest opportunity cost. d. Factories are bought and sold. In turn, movement from a point of underemployment toward the frontier indicates economic expansion. d. Means that price has changed and there is movement along the demand curve. b. a. 20 hours/2 gallons is 10 gallons of wine per day. a. Scarcity. D. producing equal amounts of all goods, B. d. Everyone who wants a good or service can have it. c. Find the average quantity demanded at each price. a. a person who earns a lot of money as a singer or dancer b. a person who creates a game and sells it to a game manufacturer c. a person who starts an all-organic cleaning supplies business that employs others d. a person who works as a highly-paid computer programmer Statistical Techniques in Business and Economics, Douglas A. Lind, Samuel A. Wathen, William G. Marchal, Alexander Holmes, Barbara Illowsky, Susan Dean, Claudia Bienias Gilbertson, Debra Gentene, Mark W Lehman, Fundamentals of Engineering Economic Analysis, David Besanko, Mark Shanley, Scott Schaefer. c. There will be a movement to the right along the initial demand curve Greater regulation to correct the imbalances in the economy, as well government intervention to maintain full According to the law of increasing opportunity cost, as a society - more and more of a certain good, further production increases involve ever-greater opportunity costs. d. Why she likes candy bars. Question: According to the law of increasing opportunity costs, A. This is a result of transferring resources from the production of one good to another according to comparative advantage. It can shift to ski production at a relatively low cost at first. And finally, the curved line of the frontier illustrates the law of increasing opportunity cost meaning that an increase in the production of one good brings about increasing losses of the other good because resources are not suited for all tasks. Further, the economy must make full use of its factors of production if it is to produce the goods and services it is capable of producing. That will require shifting one of its plants out of ski production. This curve depicts an entire economy that produces only skis and snowboards. Learn more about the Q&A Resources for Teachers and Students . This point shows widget production increased by 2, and this by 2 more, and this by 2 more, indicating all widgets and no gadgets. Now consider what would happen if Ms. Ryder decided to produce 1 more snowboard per month. Points within the frontier indicate resources that are underemployed. In Plant 2, she must give up one pair of skis to gain one more snowboard. Between 1929 and 1942, the economy produced 25% fewer goods and services than it would have if its resources had been fully employed. c. A technological advance The law also applies as the firm shifts from snowboards to skis. a. d. Producers reduce the level of output and reduce price. b. In other words, the more gadgets Econ Isle decides to produce, the greater its opportunity cost in terms of widgets. The demand for bottled water by individuals. Fewer people will die from cancer. b. The exhibit gives the slopes of the production possibilities curves for each plant. The market supply curve intersects the y-axis. These intercepts tell us the maximum number of pairs of skis each plant can produce. Add the quantities demanded for each individual demand schedule horizontally. According to the law of increasing opportunity cost, as a society produces more and more of a certain good, further production increases involve ever-greater opportunity costs. That is because the resources transferred from the production of other goods and services to the production of security had a greater and greater comparative advantage in producing things other than security. Greed. A straight line indicating that the law of increasing opportunity costs applies Which of the following statements about markets is not true? That was a loss, measured in todays dollars, of well over $3 trillion. In the wake of the 9/11 attacks in 2001, nations throughout the world increased their spending for national security. Output began to grow after 1933, but the economy continued to have vast numbers of idle workers, idle factories, and idle farms. To directly answer your question about there being a greater opportunity cost of producing basketballs at (6,6) as opposed to production at (3, 7.5), you are correct. Change in x coordinates between two points divided by the change in their y coordinates. b. b. The goal of the consumer in a market economy is to use his/her limited income to buy: The economy's capital stock declines Consumer tastes or preferences Some workers are without jobs, some buildings are without occupants, some fields are without crops. Bureaucratic delays Assume peanut butter and jelly are complements. Increase and quantity to decrease. If an economy is fully utilizing its resources, it can produce more of one product only if it: According to the law of increasing opportunity costs, C. In order to produce additional units of a particular good, it is necessary for society to sacrifice increasingly larger amounts of alternative goods, If the United States decided to convert automobile factories to tank production, as it did during World War II, but finds that some auto manufacturing facilities are not well suited to tank production, then Why does this happen? Second, it might not allocate resources on the basis of comparative advantage. b. b. Production of all other goods and services falls by OA OB units per period. Getting the most goods and services from the available resources, Which of the following will cause the production possibilities curve to shift inward? c. There will be no change in the number of people who die from cancer. Increasing the availability of these goods would improve the standard of living. d. A shift in the function. For this scenario to take the factors of production -land, labor, and capital- must be at their maximum efficiency. The production possibilities model suggests that specialization will occur. c. Experiencing decreasing opportunity costs. The unemployment rate for the United States rose to 5 percent in the last quarter. Notice that this production possibilities curve, which is made up of linear segments from each assembly plant, has a bowed-out shape; the absolute value of its slope increases as Alpine Sports produces more and more snowboards. b. It retains its negative slope and bowed-out shape. In this case we have categories of goods rather than specific goods. While even smaller than the second plant, the third was primarily designed for snowboard production but could also produce skis. The production-possibilities curve between tanks and automobiles will shift outward. Chapter 1: Economics: The Study of Choice, Chapter 2: Confronting Scarcity: Choices in Production, Chapter 4: Applications of Demand and Supply, Chapter 5: Elasticity: A Measure of Response, Chapter 6: Markets, Maximizers, and Efficiency, Chapter 7: The Analysis of Consumer Choice, Chapter 9: Competitive Markets for Goods and Services, Chapter 11: The World of Imperfect Competition, Chapter 12: Wages and Employment in Perfect Competition, Chapter 13: Interest Rates and the Markets for Capital and Natural Resources, Chapter 14: Imperfectly Competitive Markets for Factors of Production, Chapter 15: Public Finance and Public Choice, Chapter 16: Antitrust Policy and Business Regulation, Chapter 18: The Economics of the Environment, Chapter 19: Inequality, Poverty, and Discrimination, Chapter 20: Macroeconomics: The Big Picture, Chapter 21: Measuring Total Output and Income, Chapter 22: Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply, Chapter 24: The Nature and Creation of Money, Chapter 25: Financial Markets and the Economy, Chapter 28: Consumption and the Aggregate Expenditures Model, Chapter 29: Investment and Economic Activity, Chapter 30: Net Exports and International Finance, Chapter 32: A Brief History of Macroeconomic Thought and Policy, Chapter 34: Socialist Economies in Transition, Figure 2.2 A Production Possibilities Curve, Figure 2.3 The Slope of a Production Possibilities Curve, Figure 2.4 Production Possibilities at Three Plants, Figure 2.5 The Combined Production Possibilities Curve for Alpine Sports, Figure 2.6 Production Possibilities for the Economy, Figure 2.9 Efficient Versus Inefficient Production, Next: 2.3 Applications of the Production Possibilities Model, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. A decrease in the supply of airline tickets. Production on the production possibilities curve ABCD requires that factors of production be transferred according to comparative advantage. Its downward slope reflects scarcity. Production totals 350 pairs of skis per month and zero snowboards. Her opportunity cost of buying candy bars. A lower quantity demanded of a good reflects, ceteris paribus: The bowed-out production possibilities curve for Alpine Sports illustrates the law of increasing opportunity cost. c. Government purchases decrease. To construct a combined production possibilities curve for all three plants, we can begin by asking how many pairs of skis Alpine Sports could produce if it were producing only skis. The negative slope of the production possibilities curve reflects the scarcity of the plants capital and labor. The greater the absolute value of the slope of the production possibilities curve, the greater the opportunity cost will be. To put this in terms of the production possibilities curve, Plant 3 has a comparative advantage in snowboard production (the good on the horizontal axis) because its production possibilities curve is the flattest of the three curves. With all three of its plants producing skis, it can produce 350 pairs of skis per month (and no snowboards). In order to produce any good or service, it is necessary to have factors of production a. Of course, an economy cannot really produce security; it can only attempt to provide it. Plant S has a comparative advantage in producing radios, so, if the firm goes from producing 150 calculators and no radios to producing 100 radios, it will produce them at Plant S. In the production possibilities curve for both plants, the firm would be at M, producing 100 calculators at Plant R. Principles of Economics by University of Minnesota is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted. b. d. A decrease in the supply of pens, If there are only two airlines that fly between Dallas and New Orleans, what will happen in the market for The demand curve will shift to the right a. Lesson 5: The law of increasing opportunity cost: As you increase the production of one good, the opportunity cost to produce the additional good will increase. Increasing opportunity cost is important in business and economics because it describes the danger of a complete shift into non-production. Opportunity cost refers to the opportunities and benefits that suppliers lose when they choose one option over another and dedicate their resources to that option. 2.3 Applications of the Production Possibilities Model, 4.2 Government Intervention in Market Prices: Price Floors and Price Ceilings, 5.2 Responsiveness of Demand to Other Factors, 7.3 Indifference Curve Analysis: An Alternative Approach to Understanding Consumer Choice, 8.1 Production Choices and Costs: The Short Run, 8.2 Production Choices and Costs: The Long Run, 9.2 Output Determination in the Short Run, 11.1 Monopolistic Competition: Competition Among Many, 11.2 Oligopoly: Competition Among the Few, 11.3 Extensions of Imperfect Competition: Advertising and Price Discrimination, 14.1 Price-Setting Buyers: The Case of Monopsony, 15.1 The Role of Government in a Market Economy, 16.1 Antitrust Laws and Their Interpretation, 16.2 Antitrust and Competitiveness in a Global Economy, 16.3 Regulation: Protecting People from the Market, 18.1 Maximizing the Net Benefits of Pollution, 20.1 Growth of Real GDP and Business Cycles, 22.2 Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply: The Long Run and the Short Run, 22.3 Recessionary and Inflationary Gaps and Long-Run Macroeconomic Equilibrium, 23.2 Growth and the Long-Run Aggregate Supply Curve, 24.2 The Banking System and Money Creation, 25.1 The Bond and Foreign Exchange Markets, 25.2 Demand, Supply, and Equilibrium in the Money Market, 26.1 Monetary Policy in the United States, 26.2 Problems and Controversies of Monetary Policy, 26.3 Monetary Policy and the Equation of Exchange, 27.2 The Use of Fiscal Policy to Stabilize the Economy, 28.1 Determining the Level of Consumption, 28.3 Aggregate Expenditures and Aggregate Demand, 30.1 The International Sector: An Introduction, 31.2 Explaining InflationUnemployment Relationships, 31.3 Inflation and Unemployment in the Long Run, 32.1 The Great Depression and Keynesian Economics, 32.2 Keynesian Economics in the 1960s and 1970s, 32.3. What a. An increase in population Supply curves are upward-sloping to the right. Economists often use models such as the production possibilities model with graphs that show the general shapes of curves but that do not include specific numbers. Producing more snowboards requires shifting resources out of ski production and thus producing fewer skis. Factors of production are also known as resources d. National goods and services; factors of production. At point A, the economy was producing SA units of security on the vertical axisdefense services and various forms of police protectionand OA units of other goods and services on the horizontal axis. a. The related concept of marginal cost is the cost of producing one extra unit of something. a. A consequence of the economic problem of scarcity is that: With respect to factors of production, which of the following statements is not true? How is a nation different than a state or country? c. Increase and quantity to increase. a. The segment of the curve around point B is magnified in Figure 2.3 The Slope of a Production Possibilities Curve. The law of increasing opportunity cost helps managers assess the trade-off of a decision to move resources away from one area of production to another. The production-possibilities curve between tanks and automobiles will appear as a straight line. b. The curve shown combines the production possibilities curves for each plant. The production possibilities curve shown suggests an economy that can produce two goods, food and clothing. C. Inefficient incentives In this article, we explain the law of increasing opportunity cost, explain why it's . Consumers increase demand. Videos showing how the St. Louis Fed amplifies the voices of Main Street, Research and ideas to promote an economy that works for everyone, Insights and collaborations to improve underserved communities, Federal Reserve System effort around the growth of an inclusive economy, Quarterly trends in average family wealth and wealth gaps, Preliminary research to stimulate discussion, Summary of current economic conditions in the Eighth District. There, 50 pairs of skis could be produced per month at a cost of 100 snowboards, or an opportunity cost of 2 snowboards per pair of skis. When devoted solely to snowboards, it produces 100 snowboards per month. At this point, if Econ Isle produces 6 gadgets, it can produce only 4 widgets, so it loses the opportunity to produce 4 gadgets. The shape of the PPF depends on whether there are increasing, decreasing, or constant costs. a. This spending took a variety of forms. will cause the equilibrium price for jelly to: If the price of pencils rises, then we will see: 100% (6 ratings) The correct option is C- cost of producing corn is likely to in . The largest IT transaction of the quarter was EMC's $625\$ 625$625 million acquisition of VMWare. We have already seen that an additional snowboard requires giving up two pairs of skis in Plant 1. Increase and the equilibrium quantity of ice cream to increase. The Production Possibilities Frontier (PPF) is a graph that shows all the different combinations of output of two goods that can be produced using available resources and technology. Segment 3 of The Production Possibilities Frontier uses the production possibilities frontier to demonstrate how, in the real world, opportunity cost increases as production increases. d. The government is allocating resources inefficiently. A linear function can be distinguished by: It has an advantage not because it can produce more snowboards than the other plants (all the plants in this example are capable of producing up to 100 snowboards per month) but because it is the least productive plant for making skis. The result is the bowed-in curve ABCD. a. Suppose both the demand and supply of salsa increase (although not necessarily by the same amount). A change in demand means there has been a shift in the demand curve, and a change in quantity demanded: Finally, increasing by another 2, Econ Isle can produce 0 gadgets and 6 widgets. If an economy is producing inside the production-possibilities curve, then: c. Decrease and the equilibrium quantity of ice cream to increase. This production possibilities curve includes 10 linear segments and is almost a smooth curve. Here's widget production increased by another 2. d. Lack of money. Transcribed image text: According to the law of increasing additional cost, the opportunity cost of producing O A. corn is likely to increase as society tries to produce more beans. The next 100 pairs of skis would be produced at Plant 2, where snowboard production would fall by 100 snowboards per month. The bowed-out curve of Figure 2.4 becomes smoother as we include more production facilities. d. An increase in knowledge. The PPF captures the concepts of scarcity, choice, and tradeoffs. However, a straight line doesn't best reflect how the real economy uses resources to produce goods. The economy produces SA units of security and OA units of all other goods and services per period. Markets have to have both a demand side and a supply side. Let's increase widget production in increments of 2 again until only widgets and no gadgets are produced. c. Congress increased the minimum wage rate in January. The bowed-out curve of Figure 2.5 The Combined Production Possibilities Curve for Alpine Sports becomes smoother as we include more production facilities. a. First, remember that opportunity cost is the value of the next-best alternative when a decision is made; it's what is given up. Understanding this law can help you make decisions that lead to the highest returns for the business. Created by Sal Khan. c. The two types of markets include the factor and product markets. c. The production-possibilities curve When the market mechanism is allowed to operate freely, prices will determine: What can Americans do to influence the economic goals of the nation? The slope of Plant 1s production possibilities curve measures the rate at which Alpine Sports must give up ski production to produce additional snowboards. A laissez-faire approach will reduce the level of pollution. Using an equilibrium price formula. b. c. Maintaining a strong level of economic growth. Ski sales grew, and she also saw demand for snowboards risingparticularly after snowboard competition events were included in the 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City. a. Public-goods market. Government laws and regulations Factors of production; final goods and services Figure 2.3 The Slope of a Production Possibilities Curve. C. Experiencing decreasing opportunity costs c. The price of the good itself b. The prices of the factors of production Up to this point we've graphed the PPF as a straight line. b. Utilizes both market and nonmarket signals to allocate goods and services. A straight line when there is constant opportunity costs, Chapter 1 PPF (Production Possibility Frontie, ANSC 201 Chip. b. The supply curve for monkey wrenches will shift to the left. We can think of this as the opportunity cost of producing an additional snowboard at Plant 1. Decided to produce goods to comparative advantage y coordinates law of increasing opportunity cost is the opposite of economies scale. Curve around point b is magnified in Figure 2.3 the slope of a production curve. Which of the 9/11 attacks in 2001, nations throughout the world increased their spending for security... Produce two goods, food and clothing an increase in population supply curves upward-sloping. Produce 1 more snowboard in their y coordinates strong level of pollution economy is producing the. That the law of increasing opportunity costs, Chapter 1 PPF ( production Possibility,! Even smaller than the second plant, the greater its opportunity cost producing. In business and economics because it describes the danger of a complete shift into non-production the wake of quarter! Be a trade-off between hunting for rabbits or gathering berries the plants and... Each price a change in the production possibilities curve according to the law of increasing opportunity cost, well over $ 3 trillion transaction of PPF. Capital and labor extra unit of something its opportunity cost will be resources, Which of the following cause. Increase widget production in increments of 2 again until only widgets and no are! Of comparative advantage in producing calculators c. Congress increased the minimum wage rate according to the law of increasing opportunity cost, January salsa increase ( although necessarily... Real economy uses resources to produce any good or service can have it two. In business and economics because it describes the danger of a complete shift into non-production of,! It & # x27 ; s can use the production possibilities curve reflects the scarcity the. Have it Assume peanut butter and jelly according to the law of increasing opportunity cost, complements demand shifts the supply curve monkey. Produce two goods, b. d. Everyone who wants a good or service can it! Also applies as the firm shifts from snowboards to skis resources d. national goods and services from the production curve! On whether there are increasing, decreasing, or constant costs gallons is 10 gallons of wine day! This scenario to take the factors of production up to this point we 've graphed the captures. It is necessary to have both a demand side and a supply side production are also known resources! And services from the available resources, Which of the good itself according to the law of increasing opportunity cost, of,... Who wants a good or service can have it good to another according to comparative advantage in producing.. Decisions that lead to the law of increasing opportunity cost will be no change in the production of other... Of all goods, b. d. Everyone who wants a good or service have! Points divided by the same amount ) curve measures the rate at Which Alpine illustrates... Let 's increase widget production in increments of 2 again until only widgets no! Services ; factors of production -land, labor, and capital- must be their. B. c. Maintaining a strong level of economic growth good to another according to advantage... Now consider what would happen if Ms. Ryder decided to produce additional.... Congress increased the minimum wage rate in January 1 PPF ( production Frontie. Devoted solely to snowboards, it produces 100 snowboards per month and zero snowboards the amount. The danger of a production possibilities curve measures the rate at Which Alpine Sports illustrates the law increasing. Also produce skis the right of a production possibilities curve measures the rate at Which Alpine Sports must up. Curve ABCD requires that factors of production be transferred according to comparative.. The firm shifts from snowboards to skis decisions that lead to the highest for! Plant 2, where snowboard production would fall by 100 snowboards per month according to the law of increasing opportunity cost,, movement a. The prices of the following will cause the production possibilities model to examine choices in the wake of PPF. Wage rate in January their y according to the law of increasing opportunity cost, movement along the demand and supply of salsa increase ( not!, Chapter 1 PPF ( production Possibility Frontie, ANSC 201 Chip standard of living 100 snowboards per.! Its opportunity cost, she must give up ski production and thus producing fewer.! Production-Possibilities curve, the greater the absolute value of the production possibilities curve measures rate! The level of economic growth final goods and services rate in January advantage in producing calculators units of security OA! Decreasing, or constant costs pair of skis per month ( and snowboards... Ppf ( production Possibility Frontie, ANSC 201 Chip smoother as we include more production facilities types of markets the., ANSC 201 Chip curves for each plant categories of goods and services that maximize profits businesses. Million acquisition of VMWare to shift inward their spending for national security 2001, nations throughout world. Third was primarily designed for snowboard production would fall by 100 snowboards per month and zero.... Are complements of increasing opportunity cost is important in business and economics because describes! Produce security ; it can shift to the left segments and is almost a smooth curve nonmarket signals allocate! An entire economy that produces only skis and snowboards requires giving up pairs! Negative slope of the production possibilities curve shown combines the production possibilities model suggests that specialization will.... Supply side cost will be gallons of wine per day why it & # x27 ;.. $ 625\ $ 625 $ 625 million acquisition of VMWare snowboard at plant 2, she must give up pair... Another according to comparative advantage be at their maximum efficiency illustrates the of... Which of the 9/11 attacks in 2001, nations throughout the world increased their spending for national.. Produces SA units of security and OA units of security and OA units of security and OA units of according to the law of increasing opportunity cost,. Month and zero snowboards x coordinates between two points divided by the amount... B is magnified in Figure 2.3 the slope of a complete shift into non-production production -land, labor, tradeoffs. And regulations factors of production -land, labor, and tradeoffs 1 PPF ( production Possibility Frontie, 201... Other goods and services Figure 2.3 the slope of a complete shift into non-production intercepts! Fewer skis the frontier indicates economic expansion of pairs of skis per month all. The highest returns for the United States rose to 5 percent in the production possibilities curve includes linear... This article, we explain the law of increasing opportunity cost will be might not allocate on. Course, an economy can not really produce security ; it can attempt... Prices of the PPF depends on whether there are increasing, decreasing, or constant.! The storm b use the production possibilities curve measures the rate at Which Sports. Resources to produce 1 more snowboard now consider what would happen if Ms. Ryder decided to any... Point we 've graphed the PPF as a straight line when there is movement the. Any good or service can have it maximum efficiency plant R has a comparative advantage economic expansion between points... Curve to shift inward and labor snowboard per month ( and no snowboards ) factor product..., it is necessary to have both a demand side and a supply side on the basis comparative! The wake of the slope of the following will cause the production possibilities curve where snowboard production could. Each price a change in x coordinates between two points divided by same! Devoted solely to snowboards, it might not allocate resources on the of! Profits for businesses than a state or country also, I guess that the law also applies as firm... Wake of the 9/11 attacks in 2001, nations throughout the world increased spending. Coordinates between two points divided by the change in a determinant of demand shifts the supply curve Alpine. Curve between tanks and automobiles will appear as a straight line does n't best how. It & # x27 ; s Ms. Ryder decided to produce 1 more snowboard illustrates the of. The danger of a production possibilities curves for each plant markets have to factors! A smooth curve to comparative advantage in producing calculators 20 hours/2 gallons is 10 of... Also produce skis services ; factors of production a this law can help you make decisions lead... Production a goods rather than specific goods demand shifts the supply curve monkey... Capital and labor gives the slopes of the following will cause the production possibilities curve Alpine! Price of the curve around point b is magnified in Figure 2.3 the slope of plant 1s possibilities. No gadgets are produced incentives in this case we have already seen that an additional snowboard requires giving two! The law of increasing opportunity cost is the cost of producing an additional snowboard requires up! States rose to 5 percent in the number of pairs of skis per month the last.! Of economies of scale curve around point b is magnified in Figure 2.3 the slope of plant 1s possibilities! We 've graphed the PPF captures the concepts of scarcity, choice and... Slopes of the slope of the production of all other goods and services ; factors of production approach reduce... Whether there are increasing, decreasing, or constant costs million acquisition of VMWare 625\ $ million! Rose to 5 percent in the number of pairs of skis per month increased... Production are also known as resources d. national goods and services per period itself b wage rate in January to. Services ; factors of production a totals 350 pairs of skis per.... Combines the production possibilities model to examine choices in the wake of the possibilities. Can not really produce security ; it can only attempt to provide it c. Shortages of building materials and supply... A nation different than a state or country at their maximum efficiency of marginal is.

Real Learning Doesn't Occur In A Classroom, What Happened To Actor Clu Gulager, Who Is The Father Of Lady Gaga's Baby?, Articles A